MindBlog Dansk

MindLab

citizen-centred innovation - anthropological methods - service design - public development - communication - idea and concept development - innovation strategy - cross-institutional collaboration

Christian Bason

Why is innovation a terrible word?

By July 12th 2010

I’ve had my government-issue HTC smartphone for a while, but it wasn’t until recently that I noticed that the phone maker has written ‘htc innovation’ with miniscule letters on the side of the unit. As if the company wanted to make really sure that I realise I am holding an innovative piece of technology. Probably the wording was slashed on last-minute by the marketing people. ‘It can’t hurt’, they might have been thinking. Who doesn’t want innovation?

Innovation is everywhere, and everyone is claiming it. From my phone maker to producers of washing detergent to space agencies and national governments, innovation is something many people agree is somehow important, but few can really express how. ‘Innovation’ becomes a panacea for any problem because, in essence, it expresses that whatever the challenge is, it is being dealt with successfully. But like a wet bar of soap, ‘innovation’ somehow eludes a firm grip. Paradoxically, we want it, but can’t really express it. That is why, when we at MindLab drafted our communication strategy three years ago, it stated that “‘Innovation’ is a terrible word. But there’s nothing wrong with its content”.

How does innovation become a terrible word? In organisations that are not used to working in new ways, which do not enthusiastically embrace new ideas, and which do not necessarily thrive on on-going change, innovation can become a diffuse, abstract and perhaps even dangerous term. Innovation may be perceived as  anything from wild creativity, ‘letting your hair down’, to a management fad, or to loosing control to risky experimentation. No wonder that some people, and in my experience in particular people in government, dislike the word.

However, if ‘innovation’ wasn’t part of our vocabulary, we’d have to invent it. Innovation is the only term we have that captures the notion of creating something new that works. It embodies the dialectic of inspiration (generating the new ideas we need to create the future we want) and execution (the practice of getting things done to create value).

As opposed to ‘creativity’ or ‘invention’, innovation is therefore, and perhaps surprising to some, highly practical. The best of  the (vast) literature on innovation not only offers extremely useful perspectives on strategy, leadership and organisation. It offers a set of professional approaches, tools and methods which can help make the process of creating the new solutions we need, whether it be a new product or a public service, conscious, strategic and systematic.

Because the concept and practice of innovation offers us something valuable, or even essential, we need to take very seriously those who dismiss it. Rather than just slapping the word on everything we, as scholars and practitioners, say or do, we must take care to give it the meaning and content needed for the sceptics to become curious and, eventually, embrace it.

But to place the practice of innovation more squarely at the heart of government, we need to continue to show what it is, and how it works in practice. That is why we at MindLab spend so much time documenting and sharing our cases with others within the ministries we are part of, and beyond — online and in person. To be convincing, innovation has to be concrete.

As for my phone? Well, it works OK. But honestly? There are more innovative models out there.

Comments

  1. Weekly bits of interest – 19 July 2010 | Innovation Blog kl. 01.37 19/07/2010

    [...] this post, MindLab’s Innovation Director Christian Bason looks at the word innovation, what it really [...]

  2. Bill Wyatte kl. 01.57 19/07/2010

    Agree, wholeheartedly.
    Innovation is similar to sustainability in that aspect. Everyone loves the word and what it stands for, although there’s, perhaps, some reluctance to step up and deliberately do things differently to achieve it.
    I’ve chosen to not include the word “innovation” in corporate documentation I’m conceiving to promote innovation,using other words that describe it, hoping through this approach to deal with the fundamental issues rather than with the baggage that goes with any discussion about innovation.

  3. Nina S kl. 01.40 20/07/2010

    For me this post captures the essence of our current problem – I’ve started talking about ‘smart responses to challenging problems’ in an attempt to avoid using the word. Perhaps like the Innuit people who have greater than twenty words for the different types of snow, we’ll start working out the variations as ‘innovation’ becomes more integral to our everyday experience.

  4. Christian Bason kl. 23.50 15/08/2010

    Thanks for these excellent reflections, which I’ve contemplated during the wonderful Danish summer holiday season. While I agree that we can and should use other terms as well — ‘change’, ‘smart solutions’, ‘fresh thinking’ being among them — I also think we might be doing ourselves a disservice if we don’t embrace the language of innovation wholeheartedly. As I argue in a new blog post on this site, there is a pressing need for new ways of working and developing policy in government organisations To embed such new practices we do need a language that can articulate them. Doesn’t any new organisational practice need a language of its own?

  5. Strategic Innovation and Local Government National Roundtable 8 May 2012 | Public Sector Innovation Toolkit kl. 06.37 15/05/2012

    [...] personally I agree with Christian Bason (MindLab’s Innovation Director) when he said that “if ‘innovation’ wasn’t part of our vocabulary, we’d have to invent it. Innovation is [...]

  6. Structural Steel kl. 23.00 8/07/2013

    Undeniably believe that that you said. Your favourite reason seemed to be at the web the easiest factor to be aware of.
    I say to you, I definitely get irked at the same time as people consider
    concerns that they just don’t recognise about. You managed to hit the nail upon the highest and defined out the entire thing without having side-effects , folks could take a signal. Will likely be again to get more. Thanks

  7. marvel avengers alliance cheat engine kl. 10.59 28/12/2013

    Every week another AAA game is released, games that selling thousands if not millions of
    copies. Most of the people are thinking that playing this game is
    really hectic and difficult. What can you do if Avast conflicts with Real –
    Arcade games.

Comment RSS

Post a comment